Archive for January, 2007

h1

Taking Another Plunge

January 29, 2007

Or my life as a masochist…

I’m back into Linux mode, namely because I need a machine that can run some things that an old PII with 32 MB RAM can no longer handle.  And yes, this may involve running some Windows Apps.  In fact it most definitely will. So it was time to take an old 866 mhz PC with a 10 G hard drive and 320 Mb RAM and seeif I could get something installed.  Can you guess what my first choice was?  How about my second?  Which one actually ran?

Dreamlinux 2.2 was my first choice since it seemed to offer most of what I might want and need right out of the box.  However, perhaps because of the processor or the RAM it never got beyond the “Loading Thundar” screen.  I tried a couple of times to get it to load and behave, but nothing doing.  Dreamlinux 2.2 is brand spankin’ new and ran fine on my new laptop with the Intel Pentium D.  But languished mightily in the PIII environment.  Time to try something else…

Linspire 5.0 might be a possibility,  However that too got hung up twice and failed to boot on this machine.  It was looking like it was going to be a lousy day for Linux.  I wanted and needed a full distro for some potentially heavy lifting, so Puppy wasn’t going to fit the bill (although Puppy was able to play nicely on the old PII and was able to bring that dinosaur back to life).

So I went back to what I know.  And liked.  that would be Simply Mepis 6.0.  it is worth noting that for all the arrows and mud I have slung at Ubuntu, Mepis has so much in common with it as to simply be a more advance Kubuntu.  i read on reviewer who basically said Mepis was a better Kubuntu than Kubuntu.  So the live CD spooled up and I went ahead and committed the entire hard drive to Mepis.  I said goodbye to XP, at least on this machine, and in 30 minutes I had a new OS.

Nest, taking advantage of the high speed connection here, I downloaded several apps using the Synaptic Package manager.  Somewhere along the way, I heard about Automatix and thought I might like to give that a whirl.  And with that quest, I was plunging deeper into the land of the uber geeks.  For it was here that I began doing stuff with the (GASP!) Command Line.

Or at least that was my intent.  This foray was not without its adventures and frustrations.  The Automatix website was forever unavailable.  And then, using whatever voodoo mojo commands that I happened to copy and paste, I managed to get the thing installed.  At least to where it was in my K menu, which is better than I thought I would do.  However, I still get the ubiquitous “some keys could not be installed, try again later.”  I try again later and the same thing happens.  So much for that thing.

I’m eventually packing this machine up and toting it home to further test it out and possibly see what it does with a modem and a game or two.

But I’m back in the game for the time being.  We’ll see how long it lasts.

dick

h1

Ubuntu Results

January 28, 2007

Earlier last week, I booted the mighty (although much abused on this blog) Ubuntu.  How would my paras handle The King of Distros?

 

As it turned out, it wasn’t a lot different from their experiences with Mepis.  Other than a brown desktop with way cooler screen savers, they didn’t notice a better or worse experience.  This sort of surprised me.  But they all deftly navigated through the menus to find games they liked, get on the internet and otherwise get things done.  I had to reconfigure the printer again for Patience and Coach didn’t like the game choices on Ubuntu as much as Mepis.  Queen actually found the Ubuntu menu easier to navigate, finding the “power down” button a little too easily.  The bad thing about a live CD is having to reconfigure everything every time a body reboots.  I did the reconfiguring for them, as that was just slightly more than they’re used to doing.  But perhaps I’m underestimating them as Coach was eventually able to boot Puppy Linux on his own.

 

The Ubuntu trial was cut short when Mr. Khan came to write down serial numbers of machines and printers, and he configured their machine for Windows.  Now they are back to XP and pretty glad to be back.  Coach was the main one to say that he might want Mepis booted up now and again for some of the games ;-).

 

The paras, who are all “normal” computer users confirmed what we all suspected about “normal” users; they just want stuff that works.  When I’d switch up desktops, they were slightly curious, which turned into some annoyance and eventually turned to acceptance and then more annoyance when something didn’t work quite like they wanted.  It’s the massive amount  of annoyances with Windows that got many of us Linux people interested in other options  in the first place, isn’t it?  Without annoyances from Windows, Linux has no traction.

 

Ubuntu does have some neat features.  Yes, I’ve been hard on it, calling it a brown turd and all.  But the screen savers are ultra cool. And before having to shut it down, I made one other discovery: Ubuntu was able to recognize all the drives on our network.  No other distro I’ve played with has come close to that, at least as far as I know.  So I did discover one superlative or two for Ubuntu giving it some degree of elevated status.  Best distro?  I think not.  I do think it deserves as much of a chance as any other distro but the over hype kind of kills it.  I’d rather discover and be pleasantly surprised by a seemingly unknown distro than be underwhelmed by a supposed super star.  But maybe that’s just me.

 

dick   

 

h1

Fedora Core 6 v Dreamlinux: A Brief Look

January 23, 2007

I ordered some new live CDs last wek some time and they came yesterday.  Linspire 5.0, Dreamlinux 2.2 and Fedora Core 6.  That last one was even a surprise to me, as I thought I had ordered Kubuntu 6.10.  Oh well!

 

So I decided to take Fedora Core for a spin, since that is the most unusual of all the distros I had or at least the one that I knew the least about.  If you’re going to try various flavors of Linux, I highly recommend trying the most exotic ones you can find. 

                    

Fedora is far from exotic.  In fact, it looks an awful lot like Ubuntu.  A quick tour of the live CD showed be that it used the Gnome desktop, had Firefox as the main web browser, and used Abiword Gnumeric to meet office application needs. 

 

My tour of Fedora was admittedly brief.  I didn’t find anything there that particularly grabbed my attention.  It seemed like just another fairly generic Linux distro with some fairly generic applications.  When I look at a distro, I pay attention to the look, the feel, the speed and any unusual applications.  Fedora had no feature that made it stand out from any other distro that I’ve tried. 

 

My tour of Dreamlinux was even more brief, because the battery on my laptop crapped out before I got too far into it.  However, this distro definitely is unique and different compared to anything else I’ve tried.  There are screen shots to be found, and a body can see right away that it looks different. 

 

There are many more applications on this distro compared to Fedora Core or Ubuntu or PCLinuxOS or most of the other distros I have tried.  Many of these can be accessed right from the desktop or a person can go into the menu.  Not being as familiar with this type of desktop, it took some time to even find the menu.  It also has Firefox plus the full Open Office suite of programs.  It also has The Gimp and several other graphic and media editing tools making it a much more feature-packed distribution.

 

At the time my laptop crapped out, I was playing chess against the computer and actually doing pretty well 6 moves in.  It seems like if you’re going to offer some games, chess is the ultimate of the geek games and I wonder why more don’t include it.   Dreamlinux has a nifty 3-D version that gives a player a real feel for being at an actual chess board. 

 

If a body has the urge to try a different distro, I highly encourage you to try Dreamlinux.  It may not replace what you’re already using but I think it will definitely expand your view of what a Linux desktop can be.  I’m not sure if I prefer it to menu-driven XP-like interface, but it is refreshing to find something that represents some unexplored territory.  There is a good mixture of old and new programs to enable a person to get done what they need while trying out some things they may like.  I’m definitely looking at giving this one a more in-depth look.

 

I haven’t had a chance to try Linspire, yet, but am guessing it is similar enough to Freespire to make it easy to figure out.  I’ll eventually get to it and post about it when I do.

 

dick

 

 

 

 

 

h1

Mepis Results

January 19, 2007

 

My paras are trying out some Linux distributions because I have a machine that has effectively locked us out of XP.  My friendly IT person, Mr. Khan, hasn’t had a chance to remedy this so I’m using various live CDs to see how some nontechnical folks react to Linux on the desktop.

 

Their first exposure was Puppy Linux which was adequate but certainly didn’t impress any of them in any way compared to their experiences with Windows.  These are people that simply want their machines to work.  Their patience and time is limited so they are not  going to waste time tweaking.  And you can forget about command lines.  It isn’t happening.  

 

I asked Coach today what he was looking for in a computer, since they are officially searching for new one.  His wife is more computer literate than him, but he said he wanted a machine that could play music, watch DVD movies, handle pictures, play some games, do email and surf the internet.  He and his wife do online banking and online shopping and might consider doing their taxes using a computer program.

 

Is there Linux tax software?

 

They’ve been using Mepis for a week, so I thought I’d get some feedback and pass it along.

 

All 3 paras preferred Mepis over Puppy Linux.   However each has experienced some frustration with some aspect of Mepis.  Patience was unhappy because I hadn’t configured the printer so it didn’t want to print.  Once I got the printer working, she was happy.  She’s a bit of a Mahjong junkie so it didn’t take her long to find that in the games folder.

 

 

Queen is the least comfortable with it, as she is simply not used to the new icons and desktop.  She definitely prefers XP over Mepis. She’s been out for a few days so has the least experience with it and the least feedback to offer.

 

Coach was the most happy with it, as he really loved having some new games to play around with.  It took him awhile to understand and navigate the menu but once he did he explored around a bit and found what he wanted.  His main issue was not being able to use the CD drive to play a music CD because the drive was occupied by the Mepis CD.

 

Since none of them have flash or key drives, the whole mounting/unmounting thing hasn’t come up and won’t likely unless I install one of these distros.  I’m sort of waiting for the Dreamlinux CD to arrive before I change the system again.  If it’s not here by Monday, I may give Ubuntu a whirl.

 

All-in-all, Mepis has held up well in live CD mode for day-to-day use by my 3 para educators.  I occasionally have to show them how to do something, but once I show one, they share with each other.  The printing issue came up this morning and was the first time in a few days where I had to sit in front of it to get it to work. Otherwise it has worked surprisingly well.

 

dick

 

h1

Another Example of How Ubuntu Hurts Linux

January 17, 2007

 

As if I needed to say it again, one more time

 

I’ve been carping all over Ubuntu, not because it is that bad of a distro, but because it hardly represents the best, easiest or fastest distro.  Read this article by yet another disgruntled user who tried Ubuntu and walked away feeling cheated, saddened and frustrated by all of the problems with Linux.  Read the title of the article:

 

“I tried Linux and was very disappointed” (Emphasis mine)

 

THAT is the problem, and the reason why Ubuntu gets totally, totally on my very last nerve.  Ubuntu is NOT Linux any more than AOL is the internet!  It is an overhyped distro that absolutely damages the reputation of Linux and what it has to offer.  That brown shit of a distribution turned yet another frustrated XP user into a more frustrated ex-Linux refugee!  He ain’t coming back because he’s going to buy a Mac, and I say bully for Apple! 

 

The bright spot is that Linux is always improving with each new distro and each new version.  This is what makes open source work because things can move along more quickly.  Vista is just barely going to be out there on the edge, and in a year or less there will be a new Linux to surpass it.  Maybe not in every respect, but there will be some competitive choices.

 

This is why I like reading Steven J. Vaughn-Nichols, because he gives a very realistic view of what Linux needs to do to pick up more users.  Read his article for some major problems that still need to be worked out in the Linux world, and why Ubuntu is a very poor choice for people that are new to Linux.

 

dick

 

h1

An Experiment

January 17, 2007

Last summer it was kind of exciting talking about all of the various Linux distros coming out and trying them.  But lately, Linux has lost some of its luster.  Many are waiting for Vista to take over all the tech news.  Amazon sent me an email offering to sell me copies for as little as $149.99 for the basic home version.  I do not think I will be buying the newest malware magnet anytime soon.

 

Okay, my experiences with certain distros may or may not be typical for true newbies.  I’m talking people who are not power users of any sort.  The type who turn on the computer and just expect it to do stuff.  Like my para educator team.  I think I’m going to switch distros on them and see what happens.  They’ve been using Puppy Linux 2.10 for a couple of months now and I haven’t heard a lot of complaints.  They are mainly surfing the web and checking their web-based email accounts and might occasionally write something or print it out.  Sometimes they run across some cute animation, video or song they want to see or listen to.  So I’m going to see how they like and respond to different distros.  As long as it doesn’t get too disruptive, we’ll give each one a week’s worth of try-out time.  That should be plenty for them (and me) to discover any potential issues.  We’re running live CDs at the moment but will see about installing maybe later on.

 

System Hardware

 

This is a new Intel D processor machine running 2.67 G with 512 M RAM.  We are plugged into a network and the machine is also hooked to an older HP DeskJet 694c printer.  The machine has a DVD-CDRW and a floppy drive.  I’m not sure the specs on the monitor but since it came with the machine, it is new.  It is not LCD or flat panel but the older, regular 17″ type.

 

Subjects Participants

 

These are not geeks by any stretch.  They do not know or care what they are using as long as it works.  They know they are using Puppy because the screen has a giant puppy face on it.   But otherwise could care less.

 

Queen is around 50 or so, and knows the internet and email.   She has a computer at home but I don’t think uses it that much.   She’ll play an occasional game of solitaire or an online game.  The advent of the cell phone has turned her into a technophile, but computers are something she only knows so much about.

 

Patience is in her 30’s and is fairly savvy when it comes to surfing the web and technology in general.  She has a laptop that she uses at home where she gets email, plays games and writes on occasion.  She’s brought it in a time or two for me to look at in order to diagnose various annoyances and problems.

 

Coach is in his 20’s and is totally comfortable with computers and technology.  He’ll be the one wanting to download music or watch movies on his computer at home.  Here, he is mostly surfing the web.  He might actually have a fantasy football team somewhere and would play any sports game we had, if we had any.  I’m not sure what kind of game console he has at home except that he does have one.

 

But he’s obviously not a power user.  He was telling about how his computer died last night while he was surfing the internet:

Yeah, I was surfing away when it just went blank, so I rebooted it and it got stuck on the Windows 98 screen.” 

Win 98? HELLO?!?  Why don’t you just paint a sign on your virtual back that says “INFECT ME!” Ha!  Seriously, I see a new old desktop in my future.

 

Oh, and there’s me.  In my 40’s, I take apart computers and put them back together.  I do much of my reading and most of my writing on my Zaurus PDA.  But of the 4 of us, I was the last one to get a cell phone.  I’ve been fiddling with Linux for about a year now.

 

Distros

 

Puppy was the first one, and they have not complained much about it, at least to my face.  They may have issues they simply haven’t shared.  By switching the interfaces, it should give them something to complain about!

 

Mepis 6.0 and Ubuntu 6.0 will definitely be tried out.  Freespire and PCLinux are not booting up for some reason on this machine.  They both get so far in the process and then just stall.  I haven’t tried the SuSE DVD, yet.

 

I also went ahead and ordered a couple more distros that I’m interested in looking at.  One is Kubuntu 6.10.  I keep hearing how wonderful it is so I’ll see for myself how good or bad it is.  I admit my expectations are low so maybe I will be pleasantly surprised.

 

I’m more looking forward to Dreamlinux 2.2 which is supposed to be targeted for multimedia applications.  It has some new features that make it especially appealing.  One is that it has an installer that will install apps like Google’s Picasa which has given other distros I’ve tried severe indigestion.  It also has WINE preinstalled, which is a winner for me if it works.

 

Finally, I ordered Linspire 5.0 to see if that does what Freespire isn’t doing for me at the moment, mainly functioning at all. 

 

All in all, I’ll have several different distros for the paras to try out plus a few that I’ll be playing around with on my own.  Until I get that second desktop, I won’t be trying a full install anytime soon. 

 

D.

h1

Ubuntu: The Paris Hilton of Linux?

January 11, 2007

The AOL- Ubuntu connection is one of the most popular posts I’ve ever written, by virtue of Ubuntu being so popular.

 

I think this one should top it because I’m marrying the freakish with the geekish.  With any luck, I’ll never have to write another post again.  My place in blog history is sealed!

 

I’ve seen an episode or two of the various incarnation of The Simple Life.  I haven’t seen the video, but I have seen some stills from One Night in Paris.  Ms. Hilton is an attractive young lady who is probably smarter than what is depicted in the media.  But there can be no doubt about her talent for being well connected and being in the right place at the right time.  Her biggest claim to fame is being in the public eye.  She poses shamelessly for the paparazzi as her main job is to be seen.  In terms of actual skills and talents, she hasn’t shown much above mediocrity.  She’s not a great comedian and she’s not a great actor.  According to many who saw the x-rated movie, she wasn’t all that good at sex.  She actually shows some potential as a singer, if the one video clip I saw is any indication.  But in terms of actual talent, there are many, many more talented people and most of those do not get a fraction of the publicity and air time that Ms. Hilton does.  It’s sort of like just the fact that she’s popular drives even more popularity.  It’s popularity gone viral, and 2006 saw Ms. Hilton at the top of her game.

 

And so it was last year with the release of Ubuntu’s Dapper Drake.  The popularity of this Linux distribution went viral and soon a body could not even talk about Linux without mentioning Ubuntu the same way a person could not talk about Hollywood’s starlets without mentioning Paris.  Was Ubuntu the fastest distro?  No, the smaller RAM-based distros were quicker.  Was it the most powerful?  No, there were bigger and better distros out.  It was the newest for about a week.  It certainly is not the newest today.  And yet people still rave on and on about this Linux distribution.

 

Why?

 

I think the Ubuntu fan base has many things in common with Paris Hilton’s fan base.  They are perfectly willing to except something with less substance in favor of something that is simply very popular and available.  Ubuntu enjoyed a lot of exposure in 2006, and it has helped elevate the status of Linux which is a good thing.  Probably a much better thing than elevating the Hollywood social scene which Paris does.  Hundreds of Ubuntu disks have been shipped out for free and passed out among friends.  I gave out 4 of them myself to different people.  Yes, I helped fuel the Ubuntu hype.  None of those that I gave disks to have become Linux converts, tho.  I’m actually beginning to circulate more Puppy Linux disks to people because I think it is a better distribution for newbies like me, with all of those wizards to help configure things for the computer.  It’s not perfect, but it has the virtue of being faster, smaller and more feature-filled than Ubuntu. 

 

Totally unrelated, is Peter Cofee’s 25 killer apps of all time.  Unless you think Ubuntu should be one of them!  I’m just holding the link here for further future discussion and a post later on. 

 

dick